American Family Insurance Complaints in New Jersey
American Family has 9 consumer complaints on file from New Jersey, based on public NAIC and state DOI data.
Key Statistics
- Complaints in New Jersey: 9
- Total Complaints (All States): 396
- New Jersey Share: 2.3%
- NAIC Complaint Ratio: 0.82
- AI Risk Score: 35/100
Complaint Breakdown by Coverage Type in New Jersey
| Coverage Type | Complaints | % of Total |
|---|---|---|
| homeowners | 6 | 66.7% |
| auto | 3 | 33.3% |
Recent American Family Complaints in New Jersey
- homeowners Complaint #IC-MNU40MAH-ZSGDLD (2025-12-13) — Underpayment
- homeowners Complaint #IC-MNQW9V75-BM403V (2025-11-25) — Delayed payment
- homeowners Complaint #IC-MNEUNVDO-0GDE41 (2025-11-17) — Underpayment
- auto Complaint #IC-MNP3Z4G3-6UW48W (2025-11-14) — Unfair settlement
- homeowners Complaint #IC-MNOR42XH-1SX5T3 (2025-09-08) — Coverage dispute
- homeowners Complaint #IC-MNT1FOX6-CTCJ5C (2025-05-05) — Premium increase
- auto Complaint #IC-MNFTMKCP-7ZA5SN (2025-01-01) — Unfair settlement
- auto Complaint #IC-MNTR5KHN-GKF4HG (2024-07-24) — Unfair settlement
- homeowners Complaint #IC-MNESPCTA-NQ8967 (2024-04-29) — Coverage dispute
Frequently Asked Questions
How many complaints does American Family have in New Jersey?
American Family has 9 complaints on file from consumers in New Jersey, according to NAIC and state DOI data.
What types of insurance complaints are filed against American Family in New Jersey?
The top complaint categories for American Family in New Jersey are: homeowners (6), auto (3).
How does American Family's complaint record in New Jersey compare to other states?
American Family has 9 complaints in New Jersey out of 396 total complaints nationwide. That represents 2.3% of their total complaint volume.
Browse New Jersey Complaints by Category
American Family Complaints by Category
- American Family Auto Insurance Complaints
- American Family Homeowners Insurance Complaints
- American Family Health Insurance Complaints
- American Family Life Insurance Complaints
- American Family Property Insurance Complaints
- American Family Commercial Insurance Complaints
- American Family Workers Compensation Complaints
- American Family Professional Liability Complaints